How can a place brimming with resources and good intentions fail so flagrantly to meet the basic needs of the population?
Save time by listening to our audio articles as you multitaskThis question and its uncomfortable answers form the spine of “San Fransicko” by Michael Shellenberger, a former journalist who runs Environmental Progress, a non-profit group. He blames San Francisco’s woes on a culture of permissive lawlessness and a mistaken view of what constitutes moral policymaking. For example, many on the left believe the lax prosecution of laws is compassionate.
Oddly, a countercultural metropolis famed for innovation has been beset by groupthink. Activists claim San Francisco simply needs to spend more to house the homeless, without scrutinising the funds that the city already doles out to a web of unaccountable non-profits, or reckoning with the magnetic effect of its permissive policies on troubled folk elsewhere. Around 30% of the homeless population of San Francisco say they were homeless before they arrived.
Mr Shellenberger’s urge to tell the truth is brave. Those who challenge the policies espoused by advocates for the homeless are often attacked as inhumane—even though the same policies have contributed to so many unfortunates lacking access to shelter altogether. Mr Shellenberger thinks they are on the streets in part because of a “housing-first” approach, which holds out for permanent, individual homes at the expense of building enough temporary accommodation.
At its best, “San Fransicko” has the air of a spirited dinner-party conversation, as Mr Shellenberger recounts his intellectual duels with well-intentioned but wrong-headed opponents. Depressing statistics abound. Between 2014 and 2018, for instance, the number of complaints about human faeces to the city helpline doubled. There are 50% more injection drug-users in San Francisco than there are students enrolled at its public high schools.
Yet what the book offers in data, it lacks in characters. Readers are left without a strong sense of the personalities and backgrounds of Mr Shellenberger’s interlocutors. Nor is there enough analysis of the city’s dysfunctional governance. He omits to mention it, but San Francisco is the focus of anprobe that has already charged three former City Hall officials with wrongdoing.
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
The 43 best Netflix shows to watch right now (December 2022)Need a new Netflix to binge watch? Check out the 43 best series to stream right now
Read more »
Ibrahimovic shows off incredible physique in boxing ring in cheeky Christmas postZlatan Ibrahimovic may be dealing with a long spell out through injury, but that hasn’t stopped him from getting into the Christmas spirit. The AC Milan striker took to Twitter to share a fes…
Read more »
Cheeky Prince Louis shows off his outfit in adorable moment during Christmas walkaboutPrince Louis joined his siblings Prince George and Princess Charlotte for his first Christmas walkabout in Sandringham - and the festive excitement got all too much for the four-year-old royal, did you spot this sweet moment?
Read more »
Terrified children forced to flee Manchester home after Christmas Eve attackCCTV footage shows a yob hurling a brick
Read more »