Absurd offside law cannot disguise shifting of sands in Manchester | Jonathan Wilson

Australia News News

Absurd offside law cannot disguise shifting of sands in Manchester | Jonathan Wilson
Australia Latest News,Australia Headlines
  • 📰 GuardianAus
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 34 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 17%
  • Publisher: 98%

United’s controversial equaliser exposed a major flaw in the rules but also gave them a platform to close the gap on City

forward makes a run for a through-ball. The defender steps up. The ball is played and the forward is in an offside position. The forward chases the ball, following it, escorting it. Something in his head – perhaps Bruno Fernandes screaming – warns him that he might be offside and so he pulls away, allowing another forward to sweep the ball into the net. Is that forward offside?

He hasn’t touched the ball but can he be deemed to not have been interfering? Did his presence not prevent the initial defender charging back and trying to hook the ball away? It’s the sort of question that could have kept medieval theologians occupied for a lifetime. Duns Scotus and Thomas Aquinas would have written controversial tracts upon it, then those tracts would have been analysed and those analyses themselves analysed. Whole libraries would have been devoted to the theme.

But what of City? It says much about the standards they have set that a run of 14 games of which they have won nine can be regarded as a wobble. But the performance in the

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

GuardianAus /  🏆 1. in AU

Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Manchester United v Manchester City: Premier League – liveManchester United v Manchester City: Premier League – liveMinute-by-minute report: Follow all the action from the Manchester derby with Scott Murray
Read more »

Judge rejects Donald Trump's 'absurd' attempt to dismiss writer's rape lawsuitA judge says former columnist E Jean Carroll can proceed with civil lawsuits alleging she was raped by Donald Trump in a department store 25 years ago.
Read more »

Judge calls Trump’s attempt to dismiss E Jean Carroll rape lawsuit ‘absurd’Judge calls Trump’s attempt to dismiss E Jean Carroll rape lawsuit ‘absurd’Ruling made in second case brought against former president by writer who alleges he sexually assaulted her in Bergdorf Goodman
Read more »

Kevin De Bruyne’s understated genius still holds key to Manchester derby | Will UnwinKevin De Bruyne’s understated genius still holds key to Manchester derby | Will UnwinErling Haaland has hogged the headlines for Manchester City this season but it is their midfield maestro who poses the biggest threat for United
Read more »

Manchester City footballer Benjamin Mendy cleared of six rape chargesManchester City footballer Benjamin Mendy cleared of six rape chargesFrench player will face another trial after no verdicts reached on one charge of rape and one of attempted rape
Read more »

Rashford stuns Manchester City as United comeback seals derby honoursRashford stuns Manchester City as United comeback seals derby honoursBruno Fernandes and Marcus Rashford scored in four second-half minutes as Manchester United roared back for a 2-1 victory over Manchester City
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-03-13 11:47:49