+34
The story that has emerged around the warnings Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu reportedly received ahead of October 7 involves secret flights and covert phone calls.
The question of whether Benjamin Netanyahu received warnings ahead of October 7 is a key issue in Israel's upcoming election. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's explanation for the worst-ever breakdown of Israel's national security has been simple: no-one woke him up on the morning of October 7, 2023.
"There were so many warning signs, so many indications that an attack was imminent," he said last month. "Had they woken me up, everything would have looked different. That is the story of October 7th. That is the story.
" But with only weeks to go until elections in Israel, an unrelenting stream of well-sourced, detailed stories has suddenly appeared, documenting multiple failures by the PM to either heed warnings of a possible Hamas strike, or to seize early opportunities to rescue the hundreds of hostages taken by the terrorist group. What has given an electrifying geopolitical edge to the story is that the revelations over the last month are sourced to some of the most powerful figures in the Middle East, including senior figures from the United Arab Emirates and Egypt, multiple Israeli defence and intelligence sources and sources in the United States.
Netanyahu has branded as "lies" the stories that include details of secret flights and covert phone calls. But tellingly they have not been denied by other governments. And now the former head of Shin Bet, Ronen Bar has declared he will sue Netanyahu for defamation, saying that he had warned the PM "of an impending disaster, and he ignored me".
On September 8, Haaretz reported UAE President Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed had called Netanyahu a week and a half before October 7, warning him that Hamas' leader in Gaza, Yahya Sinwar, was planning a major operation against Israel.
"The emir explained that, in his assessment, Sinwar was preparing for a major event," an adviser who sat in on the conversation told Haaretz. To MBZ's reported surprise, Netanyahu downplayed the risks. What is more, the reports revealed he had not passed on the warnings to Israeli defence and security chiefs.
"Prime Minister Netanyahu didn't speak to the president of the UAE during the period in question and received no warning from him," the post said. In the complex world of Middle Eastern politics, this story is not just a case of implacable regional enemies seeking to damage Netanyahu.
The UAE is one of the Gulf countries with the strongest ties to Israel and since the February 28 attack on Iran is seen as the Gulf state most closely aligned with the US-Israeli mission. In response to the Haaretz story, the UAE Ministry of Foreign Affairs conspicuously issued what is known in the trade as a "non-denial denial".
"The UAE Government does not comment on media stories or speculation regarding conversations between government leaders," it posted. But it said its engagement since October 7 was "consistently directed toward de-escalation, regional stability and preventing violence" and that "when necessary, all relevant intelligence has been and continues to be communicated between the relevant entities".
Another twist emerged this week when reports surfaced that Netanyahu had reportedly made a secret dash to the UAE on Sunday and met with MBZ.that Netanyahu asked the Emirati president to deny reports of their phone conversation and any details concerning the events of October 7 that could embarrass him. The Israeli public broadcaster subsequently said that Netanyahu's visit to Abu Dhabi came at the same time as there were incoming flights from Libya, Morocco, Qatar and the UAE, suggesting the visit was to discuss Iran.
But the problem for Netanyahu is that it is not just this report of one warning overlooked, even if it was a phone call from a powerful figure in the region. The newspaper, citing five former senior Israeli officials, reported that the warning from the Emirati leader "never reached the leaders of Israel's security establishment".
Instead, when Netanyahu gathered his security chiefs on October 1, 2023, for a meeting about the situation in the Gaza Strip, "he told them that the goal should be to maintain calm in Gaza", the minutes show, according to the paper.
"Netanyahu said that any Israeli action in Gaza might sabotage the prospect of Saudi Arabia establishing diplomatic relations with Israel — a deal the Israeli prime minister believed was imminent," the New York Times reported.reported that on September 26, 2023, Egypt's intelligence chief, Abbas Kamel, had flown to Tel Aviv's Ben Gurion Airport with another warning. "Hamas, the Muslim Brotherhood–aligned terrorist group that controlled Gaza appeared to be mobilizing for a major attack," Kamel said, according to Israeli, Egyptian, Arab, US, and European officials who were briefed about his visit after October 7.
Kamel's message was that the window to prevent a disaster was closing. He recommended that the Israeli government grant Hamas economic concessions to avert conflict. The Atlantic, citing US, Egyptian and Israeli officials, said that even after this visit "Egypt continued to raise the alarm up until two days before the attack".
While most of the warnings that Israel received in 2023 contained no date, target, or method of attack, the intelligence officials who spoke to all these media outlets observed that they were frequent and persistent enough that they should have been listened to. It said that by early October 2023, "two Egyptian warnings about signs of an impending attack from Gaza had gone unheeded by Israel". That included Kamel's lightning visit in person.
The WSJ reported, citing officials in an Arab government, that "Kamel called Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to deliver a third alert". In the lead-up to October 7, tensions within Gaza were already conspicuously high because of a freeze on deliveries of fuel, and because Israel had closed the primary pedestrian crossing between Gaza and Israel, depriving 18,000 Gazans of access to work.
What is particularly tragic for the people of Israel, and the people of Gaza, was that it has emerged there were serious peace talks going on between Israel and Hamas — via intermediaries — in 2023. The combined reporting of Haaretz and others has also documented that Netanyahu and his far-right cabinet colleagues rejected early opportunities in the wake of the October 7 attack to get hostages back from Gaza.
Haaretz reported this month that Qatar had intervened with Hamas to help get the hostages back, but when the Qatari prime minister conveyed to the head of Mossad a deal that would have allowed them to return home without any major conditions, the offer was rejected. Netanyahu has repeatedly rejected calls for a commission of inquiry into the events leading up to October 7.
But the issue remains huge in a country where almost everything is seen through a security lens.
October 7 Hamas Did Netanyahu Know About October 7 October 7 Warnings Mossad Israel Election Nyt October 7 Warnings The Atlantic October 7 Haaretz October 7
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
ASX Flat Ahead of RBA Rate Decision as US Yields Hit 19-Year HighASX set for a flat open ahead of the RBA rate decision, while US 10-year Treasury yields hit a 19-year high and oil prices eased on Iran deal hopes.
Read more »
Kangaroos captain makes injury admission ahead of World CupAustralia are counting the cost of Penrith’s defeat with three stars now unlikely for the tournament.
Read more »
Republic of Ireland put controversy aside to earn impressive win over IsraelFirst-half goals from Troy Parrott, Adam Idah and Jack Moylan gave Ireland a 3-0 win against Israel in a near-empty stadium in Debrecen
Read more »
Hamas commander killed in Gaza air strikeIsraeli and Palestinian officials confirmed the death of Izz al-Din Al-Beik, head of Hamas' armed wing in northern Gaza, in an Israeli air strike. The Israeli military claims to have killed at least 20 Hamas figures this month, while Hamas denies accusations of rearming and violating the ceasefire. The conflict has resulted in significant casualties on both sides.
Read more »