Ben Roberts-Smith’s fate in the hands of one man | DeborahSnow MWhitbourn
have taken the calculated risk of mounting a truth defence. That means their legal team, headed by Nicholas Owens, SC, had to convince the judge that the war crimes and other wrongdoing alleged by star investigative reporters Nick McKenzie and Chris Masters were, on the balance of probabilities, true.
He also pointed out that if the judge accepted all the evidence from the media outlets as to the five unlawful killings of unarmed prisoners that Nine alleges, this would implicate other soldiers –particularly the SAS witnesses known as Person 4 and Person 11. Nine’s legal team, however, believes the war crimes case it has painstakingly built over the past year is strong enough to withstand the Briginshaw test. “Nothing left on the table,” is how one participant summed up the mood on the media outlets’ side this week.
But Owens, utterly rejecting this, emphasised that many of Nine’s critical witnesses had never had any contact with the journalists. The hearings have taken a heavy toll on some of the soldiers who gave evidence, as demonstrated by the occasionally distressed state of some in the witness box. Moses branded two of Nine’s witnesses as liars and perjurers, and says others are mistaken because of mental health conditions which distorted their memory.
Another evidentiary tussle turned on whether the media outlets should have summoned an Afghan soldier known as Person 12 to give evidence. Person 12 was a senior Afghan officer who is said to have ordered the execution of another unarmed detainee at Chenartu, in Afghanistan, in late 2012, under pressure from Roberts-Smith.Citing a precedent in a case known as Jones v Dunkel, Moses said Besanko should draw an adverse inference against Nine because of its failure to call Person 12.
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Ben Roberts-Smith’s defamation trial laid bare the brutal reality of Australia’s decades-long war in Afghanistan – now the ex-soldier awaits judgmentWhile costs of about $25m and possibly millions in damages are at stake, the trial also has existential implications for Australian journalism
Read more »
Ben Roberts-Smith’s defamation trial laid bare the brutal reality of Australia’s decades-long war in Afghanistan – now the ex-soldier awaits judgmentWhile costs of about $25m and possibly millions in damages are at stake, the trial also has existential implications for Australian journalism
Read more »
Symbols of love mask lingering anxiety of flood-hit residents in LismoreNorthern rivers community waits for an independent NSW inquiry’s findings to learn their fate
Read more »
Eels down 12-man Panthers to keep top four hopes aliveA stunning first half performance propelled Parramatta to a 34-10 win against a Penrith outfit reduced to 12 men for 62 minutes after the send-off of star playmaker Nathan Cleary.
Read more »
California court upholds death penalty in '80s sex slave murdersThe California Supreme Court has upheld the conviction and death penalty for one of two men implicated in at least 11 notorious horrific torture-slayings in the mid-1980s.
Read more »
Meet the Australians on Quantum Computing's cutting edgeAussie Universities are being hand picked to help develop Google's quantum computers. 9News
Read more »