The scathing review recommends drastic action at the inner-city clinics or face a complete government takeover.
The board of prominent inner-Melbourne medical provider cohealth faces being sacked and replaced by a state administrator following widespread financial and management failures, a The scathing review, released by the federal government on Wednesday, recommends that Victorian Health Minister Harriet Shing issues cohealth a formal final warning to prove it is effectively run, or face a complete government takeover.
An attendee holds a placard during an emergency public meeting at Fitzroy Town Hall last year about the cohealth closures. Under the Health Services Act, the state government holds powers to appoint an administrator to seize control of community health assets if local governance fails. The review panel said intervention was now required after cohealth’s executive management kept its soaring deficits hidden from the board by using reassuring language in formal paperwork until February 2024.
“It’s my strong expectation that cohealth demonstrates the integrity, transparency and accountability required to deliver the important health services some of our most vulnerable community members rely on,” she said, adding that the state government provided $68 million to cohealth last year.. Last year, the 137-year-old institution announced it would stop providing primary care and counselling services at its Kensington, Fitzroy and Collingwood sites due to a funding shortfall.
The closures would have affected more than 12,000 patients who need bulk-billing services – including vulnerable people from nearby public housing estates, homeless clients and those with drug and alcohol issues. At the time, cohealth blamed the situation on inadequate Medicare rebates for complex patients – who create a heavy, unbillable administrative workload and have high rates of non-attendance – and a lack of state government funding to upgrade the Collingwood facility.
While the independent panel confirmed that Medicare models were poorly suited for how cohealth clinics operated, it also detailed systemic internal failures and found deficits had escalated for a decade. The review was heavily critical of cohealth’s administrative structure, finding that corporate overhead costs were significantly higher than the 10 per cent to 30 per cent norm seen in comparable community health programs.
To resolve the crisis, the report recommends shifting cohealth to a trial federal grant model that replaces standard Medicare billing with a flexible pool of funding. The review also explicitly recommends that the Victorian government reconsider a previous proposal to redevelop the crumbling Collingwood site with a new GP clinic with high-density social housing towers constructed directly above it.
Shing said the government was looking at options to modernise the Hoddle Street site, including advocating for the Commonwealth to deliver the project as part of their Housing Australia Future Fund. Royal Australian College of General Practitioners Victoria Chair Dr Anita Munoz said the review provided a critical lesson for cohealth.
“There are elements of the government that cohealth need to reform in order to go into the future, and my understanding is that the CEO and the remaining executives ... will certainly be taking those recommendations very seriously. ”She said the review highlighted that the Medicare Benefit Scheme was not meeting the needs of people with complex, chronic diseases.
“The MBS is failing vulnerable populations,” she said. , it unveiled $1.5 million of funding and last month, it announced another $1.5 million to keep services afloat for another 12 months.
“There’s a certain moral injury watching the government let the vulnerable population of cohealth go without their services and yet creating services in areas that just replace existing practices,” she said, referring to a recent federal government funding announcement of $25 million to open six new bulk-billing clinics on the central coast of New South Wales. Dr Stephen Alomes, an adjunct associate professor at Deakin University and spokesman for Save Our Community Health, said cohealth’s board and senior management had failed the basic standards of governance and needed to go.
“The key recommendations suggest that cohealth is rather like a failed football coach. Its poor governance confirms that it cannot reshape the community health future,” he said. A spokeswoman for the federal government said it would consider all recommendations in the review, but did not directly respond to questions about whether it would establish the funding trial. Instead, she highlighted the recommendations that “identified the need for changes to cohealth’s governance, management and service delivery models”.
On Wednesday, cohealth thanked the reviewers for their report, saying it accepted that its governance needed to improve, but also said the review made it clear that state and federal government assistance was needed to overhaul its model.
“cohealth is sorry for the trauma, uncertainty and distress experienced by clients, staff and community throughout this process,” a spokesperson said in a statement.is a journalist in the City team at The Age. Contact her at rachael.dexter@theage.com.au, rachaeldexter@protonmail.com, or via Signal at @rachaeldexter.58is a senior reporter covering health for The Age. Henrietta joined The Age in 2012 and has previously covered state politics, education and consumer affairs.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
ATSB investigates engine shut down in remote plane crashThe Australian Transport Safety Bureau releases its preliminary report into how a small aircraft crashed in mangroves, with five passengers and two pilots on board.
Read more »
NSW Government Provides $1 Million Bailout to Struggling Australian Opal CentreThe Australian Opal Centre Limited received a $1 million grant from the New South Wales government to settle debts linked to its unfinished opal museum in Lightning Ridge. The not‑for‑profit had previously secured almost $30 million in federal, state and local grants before construction stalled last year. Following an audit that flagged a material uncertainty and a $5.4 million cash loss, the organisation cut staff, closed its shopfront and scaled back operations while planning a relaunch in 2027. The bailout aims to clear outstanding contractor and consultant debts, giving the board confidence to rebuild the national gemstone monument.
Read more »
Cricket Victoria Reverses Course, Plans to Sell Melbourne Renegades Licence Amid Big Bash League Financial CrisisFaced with a mounting financial crisis, Cricket Victoria has abandoned its earlier opposition and now plans to sell its Melbourne Renegades Big Bash League licence. The decision follows a dramatic reassessment of Cricket Australia's funding shortfall, which escalated from an estimated $90 million to nearly $400 million. The state body will rebrand the Melbourne Stars and place the Renegades in caretaker mode ahead of the sale, aiming to create a unified Victorian team identity while navigating complex board approvals and player contract transfers.
Read more »
Yacht intercepted by police off Exmouth allegedly carrying outlaw gang memberWA Police and Australian Federal Police intercepted a yacht off the coast of Exmouth in northern WA which allegedly had a Queensland fugitive on board.
Read more »