Down Goes Brown: The case against the Hall of Fame candidacies of 15 NHL stars

Australia News News

Down Goes Brown: The case against the Hall of Fame candidacies of 15 NHL stars
Australia Latest News,Australia Headlines
  • 📰 TheAthletic
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 66 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 30%
  • Publisher: 63%

It's time to flip the script, writes DownGoesBrown. No more making Hall of Fame cases for players. It's time to come up with arguments for why players 𝙨𝙝𝙤𝙪𝙡𝙙𝙣'𝙩 receive an invite to hockey's most illustrious club.

Except for maybe one guy …Joseph is another one of the overlooked goalies, but I’m separating him out because I think he’s the strongest case. In fact, he would have my vote, so I’m doing that disingenuous sportswriter thing where I argue a case I don’t really believe.

team, and his Olympic gold medal came in a year where he lost the starter’s job during the tournament. He was a regular-season winner, but maybe that’s not enough.The case against Larmer is that there’s never really been a solid case for him. Yes, he had over 1,000 points, although only barely and after a 15-year career that overlapped with the highest-scoring era of all time. Yes, he had an impressive ironman streak — so did.

It just didn’t last. By 1994, Roenick was absolutely on a HHOF track, with room to spare. But after he left Chicago, he went from being a superstar to just a guy. He had three straight 100-point seasons in Chicago, then never even got to 80 again. The dead puck era was a big part of that, and he still managed to get just past the 500-goal and 1,200-point plateaus, so there’s a case here. It’s just one that peaks too early.

The flip side of the Tkachuk case is LeClair, who had a much better peak but couldn’t reach the same career numbers. He was a first-team All-Star at left wing twice — both the years that Tkachuk was second — and a second-teamer three other times. He had two top-seven Hart finishes and three straight 50-goal seasons. For a five-year stretch, he was the best left winger in the NHL, and that kind of peak is usually enough.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

TheAthletic /  🏆 54. in UK

Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

O'Neil: Only room for sadness in Bob Huggins' latest issueO'Neil: Only room for sadness in Bob Huggins' latest issueAlready on thin ice after his derogatory remarks towards the LGBTQ+ and Catholic community on a radio show last month, Bob Huggins has handed West Virginia his job on a platter. There’s nothing funny here. It's nothing but sad, writes DanaONeilWriter.
Read more »

Flip or Flop's Christina Hall's major hair makeover revealed just in time for summerFlip or Flop's Christina Hall's major hair makeover revealed just in time for summerThe Christina on the Coast host will turn 40 next month
Read more »

Watch live theatre in the grounds of historic hallWatch live theatre in the grounds of historic hallPeople can watch live theatre in the grounds on a historic hall
Read more »

Conservative London mayoral hopefuls battle it outConservative London mayoral hopefuls battle it outDespite being rarely out of the headlines, former mayor and prime minister Boris Johnson was barely mentioned during the hustings
Read more »

For Giants' Mike Yastrzemski, Father's Day reflections encompass four generationsFor Giants' Mike Yastrzemski, Father's Day reflections encompass four generationsWhen Mike Yastrzemski suits up for the Giants on Father’s Day, he'll think of the family name he proudly represents. Yastrzemski talked to extrabaggs about the challenges his late father, Carl Michael, faced growing up as the son of baseball royalty.
Read more »

'I'm a daft Manc k***head having a laugh': Gay comic Josh Jones' rise to fame'I'm a daft Manc k***head having a laugh': Gay comic Josh Jones' rise to fame'I always think when I do a TV show and there's a load of comics, I get told to watch what I'm saying. But I can't help it - I have got a gutter mouth, it just flows out of me'
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-03-06 16:14:12