+34
The judge has explained the decision after Luke Sayers wanted the defamation case moved to another court.
Cate Sayers wanted a Victorian Supreme Court jury to decide whether her estranged husband defamed her. She claims he did so in a statuary declaration, which accused her of accessing his X account, posting a photograph of his genitalia in January 2025 and tagging a female executive at Bupa.
The document was sworn by Mr Sayers in the weeks after the controversial post, which was quickly deleted, as the AFL and Carlton conducted investigations. In May, Mr Sayers, a former PwC chief executive, applied to have the case transferred to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia where the matter would be heard in private.
But Supreme Court Justice Andrew Watson on Wednesday rejected Mr Sayers’ application, finding the Supreme Court was the more appropriate venue for a defamation claim. Credit: AAP “This court has a long history of trying defamation proceedings,” the judge wrote in his published reasons.
“There is no doubt that judges of the Family Court would have the requisite skills and experience to decide a defamation matter in that court but there are, in my view, features of this case which mean that it is not more appropriate to transfer this proceeding to that jurisdiction. ” An important function of defamation proceedings was giving defendants the chance to vindicate their reputations, the judge said.
“The Family Court has strict provisions restricting publication regarding the course of proceedings in that court,” Justice Watson said. “I accept Cate’s submission that those provisions sit at odds with the vindication function that a defamation trial would ordinarily serve. ” Mrs Sayers had sought for the case to be heard before a jury but Justice Watson rejected her application as well.
“Apart from her reliance on her claim in defamation, Cate provides no positive basis on which she asserts the discretion to order a jury trial should be exercised in her favour,” the judge said.
AFL Sport Carlton Blues News Courts & Justice Lifestyle Sponsored Content Sport
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Longmire Unapproached by Essendon and Carlton as Coaching Search BeginsSydney premiership coach John Longmire remains unattached to Essendon or Carlton's senior coaching vacancies despite being a potential top target. Essendon's search is in its infancy, with a panel formed but criteria not yet set. Carlton are expected to scout assistant coaches, while ex-Port Adelaide's Ken Hinkley stresses the need to resolve James Hird's situation first.
Read more »
Breaking: Legal fight involving ex-Carlton president Luke Sayers to play out publiclyA bid by Mr Sayers to have a defamation case brought by his wife over a nude photo scandal heard privately has been rejected by a judge.
Read more »
Cate Sayers Wins Defamation Case Venue Dispute Against Husband Luke SayersCate Sayers secured a victory in her defamation lawsuit against her ex-husband Luke Sayers, as a judge ruled the case should remain in the Supreme Court of Victoria rather than being moved to federal court. The decision favored Cate's argument that a federal court hearing could lead to reporting restrictions and limit public vindication. The judge also ordered a judge-alone trial, dismissing her request for a jury. The dispute centers on allegations that Luke Sayers falsely claimed Cate posted an explicit image of him and made other defamatory statements in a statutory declaration sent to AFL officials.
Read more »
AFL News: Carlton's Coaching Search, Bobby Hill's Return, and Umpiring ControversyCarlton's coaching search continues with the highly-rated assistants likely to be the first candidates contacted, while Collingwood's Bobby Hill has returned to training after a brief leave. Umpiring great Ray 'Razor' Chamberlain says the Nick Watson non-goal call was wrong.
Read more »