+34
Archeologists warn AI summaries can repeat false claims about 12,000-year-old rock art from Western Australia’s Kimberley region being painted by aliens
False claims about Aboriginal rock art and aliens were once fringe. Researchers fear AI could push them mainstream Archeologists warn AI summaries can repeat false claims about 12,000-year-old rock art from Western Australia’s Kimberley region being painted by aliensThis article contains historical records that use racist and offensive language, and descriptions of events that will be distressing to some readers Traditional owner Warren Barunga says he is angry that people are misusing his people’s sacred rock paintings.
Now the old tropes about the sacred rock art, born in the 19th century, have been supercharged by social media. , researchers have analysed the “extent to which popularised fringe narratives are displacing science-based and Indigenous knowledge-informed archaeology online” and the further dangers posed by AI summaries absorbing those narratives.
Countless social media accounts, some with tens of thousands of followers, falsely claim that the figures in Kimberley rock art were painted by a different or “superior” race, and possibly aliens. The researchers, from various Australian universities, looked at examples in the Pacific as well as the Gwion Gwion paintings. The Gwion Gwion paintings, which feature tall, thin people with intricate details such as complex headdresses, were introduced to Europeans by the pastoralist Joseph Bradshaw in the 1890s.
They are about 12,000 years old, and are often flanked by Wandjina, which are up to 5,000 years old. Both are used in the false claims.
“It is our kinship system … our cultural heritage … our way of life,” he says. “When I hear about these misinterpretations, it not only saddens but it angers me. ” Of the Gwion Gwion, he says they are “the first people, our ancestors. They were here; we are the children that belong to them.
”The use of “pseudoarchaeology” to make false claims about the paintings and other ancient artefacts has a long history. The “‘lunatic fringe’ of prehistoric archaeology rose in Germany in the 1920s and 30s, essentially as an “ideologically motivated misinformation scheme”, the researchers write. The Swiss author Erich von Däniken’s 1968 bestseller Chariots of the Gods? suggested we were all the descendants of aliens who visited Earth in the distant past.
Cave paintings, Egypt’s pyramids and the Easter Island statues were proof of their visit, he wrote, arguing the people who lived there would not have been capable of creating them. Speculation about a “non-Aboriginal origin” of the Kimberley figures started in the 19th century and re-emerged in the 1990s, in the context of Mabo and native title.
In 2015, then Liberal Democratic Party senator David Leyonhjelm cited the Gwion Gwion paintings when he claimed there might have been a “ He used that false claim to argue it was “not necessarily a good thing” to recognise Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the constitution. Last year, online images circulating with posts claiming to feature the Gwion Gwion were thoroughly debunked by experts.
The same picture had been previously posted with the claim it was an ancient Indian cave painting depicting the “groundbreaking revelation of prehistoric extraterrestrial encounters”. A search today of social media shows multiple accounts posting false claims about the origin of Kimberley paintings, often featuring Wandjina figures, alongside the Gwion Gwion, with speculation that with their large heads and eyes they might be alien “greys”.
The researchers say the rise of social media and AI as primary sources of information for many raises concerns about “how the outputs will influence how the past is written for mainstream audiences”. The paper’s lead author, Dr Michelle Richards, a University of Melbourne archaeologist, says academic research struggles to get into the public realm and has to compete with “fringe narratives, pseudoscience, even just made up stories … they have that promise of mystery, dramatic revelations”.
The OpenAI chat bot said definitively they were painted by Aboriginal Australians and reflected a “long, continuous cultural tradition”. When Guardian Australia asked ChatGPT about them, it said they were “most likely” painted by the ancestors of Aboriginal people and that there had been “considerable debate about their origins”, but that answer varied when different variations of the question were asked.
Richards says: “I think we still have a chance to stay on top of it, but we do have to pay attention. ”
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Australian researchers develop cryogenic cooling technology for artificial intelligenceAustralian scientists are developing a world-first cryogenic cooling system that could reduce the water and power required by artificial intelligence data centres. The technology uses very low-temperature gases to cool computing systems, potentially allowing large-scale data centres to operate near renewable energy sources and in regional areas.
Read more »
Australian researchers pursue safer cancer treatments for childrenAustralian researchers are developing targeted cancer therapies for children that aim to reduce the lifelong health effects caused by adult chemotherapy and radiation. The government is investing $5 million to bring international CAR-T trials to Australia, expanding access to advanced immunotherapy for young patients.
Read more »
European Entry System Glitches Cause False Accusations for Australian TravelersAustralians in Europe's Schengen Area are facing problems with the EES, a digital entry system plagued by glitches, leading to false accusations of overstaying.
Read more »
First Nations leaders call for WA Aboriginal children's advocate and independent peak bodyA Perth roundtable led by National Commissioner Sue-Anne Hunter has urged the WA Government to act on the rights and safety of First Nations children
Read more »