+34
Mayor Sarah Dixson admitted she looked up the private address of a pro-housing advocate after he submitted a form to speak at the council meeting.
One admission tipped the temperature inside Woollahra Council’s chambers almost to boiling point. More than 10 pro-housing advocates spoke at the public forum and were met with staunch opposition and questioning from some of the 13 councillors who attended.
The meeting featured numerous interjections, tetchy back-and-forth exchanges, and multiple points of order were called. At one point, Liberal mayor Sarah Dixson said she was “one word away” from calling an adjournment to turn the temperature down. About 40 minutes into the five-hour-long meeting, it was a personal question that almost tipped the temperature in the room to boiling point.
It began when councillor Mary-Lou Jarvis asked Sydney YIMBY’s chair Justin Simon if he could afford to buy a freestanding house with a median price of $5.4 million in Elizabeth Bay, quoting figures from realestate.com.au. Dixson interjected, and revealed she had looked up Simon’s home address before he spoke at the meeting: “Hang on, I mean I’ve looked at the cost of your house, and you certainly could afford to, you certainly could.
Advertisement Simon’s reaction was one of disbelief: “Sorry, so the cost of my home ... So you’ve taken my address that I signed up for to speak at council, and you’ve then gone and looked up my home on realestate.com? That’s such a bizarre … ”Before their terse exchange drew to a close, Simon called on the mayor to share where she lived or how much her house was worth, to which she responded curtly: “I don’t own a house.
” Justin has since criticised Dixson for accessing his private address through a form he submitted to the council, and said it was a “gotcha moment” aimed at “launching personal attacks on speakers” if they did not agree with her views on the state government’s housing plan.
“I’ve spoken at councils dozens of times over the last few years, and I’ve never had anything like this happen before,” he said. “How can people have confidence signing up to speak at Woollahra Council knowing that this is how their information is handled? This kind of privacy violation will have a chilling effect on community participation.
”To register to speak at public forums, members of the public fill out a form and provide their full name, address, phone number, and email address. Speakers must agree to a condition that states their face, voice, and personal information will be recorded and publicly accessible on the council’s website. Asked why she accessed Simon’s address, Dixson said: “It’s publicly available information and was relevant to proving that claims made by the speaker were simply incorrect.
Advertisement Dixson did not respond when asked if she had breached the code of conduct, searched for the addresses of any other speakers, and did not confirm if she accessed Simon’s details independently or through a council staff member. Simon said the mayor’s action strayed far from debate about public policy and was an attempt to turn the conversation personal.
“It potentially is a way to discourage participation from your opponents,” he said. “It reflects the weakness of her position that she feels the need to fall back on that. ” Simon said he would submit a complaint to the Office of Local Government.
Under Woollahra Council’s code of conduct policy, which sets the minimum standards of behaviour, integrity, and performance expected, councillors must “only access council information needed for council business, and not use that council information for private purposes”. Academic Andy Asquith, who researches governance matters in local councils, said the behaviour benchmarks had vague wording, and therefore made it unclear whether the mayor had breached the policy.
“It’s not a level playing field, you expect everyone is playing by the same rules … That sort of information is operational and should be accessed by a very small number of council employees, so the fact that the mayor accessed it is where the issue lies,” Asquith said. Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights.
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Brisbane council ordered to pay $675k to cyclist who lost eye on metal stakeBrisbane City Council must pay $675,926.77 plus interest and costs to Victor Dennison, whose left eye was destroyed when he crashed into an unlit barricade in 2009. The Court of Appeal overturned an earlier ruling that the council was not liable.
Read more »
Australian Imams Council Condemns Preacher's Call to Take Up ArmsThe Australian National Imams' Council expressed deep concern over a Melbourne preacher's sermon allegedly calling Muslims to take up arms against enemies and reject Jews and Christians as friends. The preacher, Abu Ahmad, disputed the interpretation, stating the remarks were drawn from a religious text and clarified that the teachings do not permit harming peaceful non-Muslims.
Read more »
Melbourne Council Votes to Stop Campaigning for Australia Day Date ChangeThe City of Melbourne has decided to cease its advocacy for moving Australia Day from January 26, acknowledging the decision lies with the federal government. While Lord Mayor Nicholas Reece personally supports changing the date, the council will continue to host events including the Share the Spirit Festival and citizenship ceremonies on January 26.
Read more »
Game of Thrones at Woollahra Council as plan to overturn mayor backfiresEven the shenanigans of Strathfield Council, as featured in Operation Rosny, were enough of a warning for a clutch of eastern suburbs councillors.
Read more »