+34
Stephen Fane Noga is appealing against a Supreme Court decision, after he was sued by one of his former Hobart Matriculation College students for allegedly sexually abusing her in the 1980s.
Hobart man Stephen Fane Noga is appealing against a Supreme Court decision, after he was found liable for sexually abusing his student in the 1980s.
Mr Noga's legal team is arguing that a series of social media posts made by the judge before and during the civil trial may have influenced his decision. A Tasmanian court has heard that there was "no logical connection" between social media posts made by a trial judge that were sympathetic to victims of child sexual abuse, and his finding in favour of the woman who alleged she was raped by a former teacher.was sued by one of his former Hobart Matriculation College students, now aged in her 60s, for allegedly sexually abusing her in the 1980s.
Stephen Noga's legal team argues that certain social media posts made by a Supreme Court justice are grounds for a successful appeal. According to the appeal filed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Tasmania, Mr Noga has appealed against the decision on four grounds — one of which is regarding social media posts and reposts made by Justice Estcourt "before, during and after" the trial which contained "material generally supportive of victims of sexual abuse".
"Resulting in a perception that the trial judge may have been more readily inclined to accept case, or find in favour of , rather than independently deciding the action on its merits," the appeal stated. The lawyer for the plaintiff, Bruce McTaggart KC, told the court that there was "no logical connection" between the posts and the matter Justice Estcourt was presiding over, and that the allegation that he was biased to the proceedings was inaccurate.
"Ninety-nine point nine per cent of the population, including judges, would have sympathy for victims of child sexual abuse. "Assuming he had posted that as an expression of sympathy … it doesn't mean a judge can't bring a fair and impartial mind to determining if someone is a victim, in this case, whether the plaintiff was raped, as she alleged.
"The lawyer for Mr Noga, Chris Gunson SC, told the court that there was a "logical connection" between the posts and the outcome. "If are looked at as a collection over a period of time, the general theme of the posts is public expressions of sympathy or support of victims of child sex abuse more generally," he said.
Mr Gunson has also defended his decision to not report the post, when it was first given to his legal team, during the trial earlier in the year.
"There was a considered decision, I was of the view that it didn't get to the level of itself justifying his honour to recuse himself," Mr Gunson said. Mr McTaggart told the court that this decision was calculated.
"Rather than bring it to the judge's attention and provide him with the opportunity of correcting any wrong impression, that did not occur," Mr McTaggart said. Mr Noga's legal team is also appealing against Justice Estcourt's decision on the three other grounds, alleging that he "erred in law", including by criticising Mr Noga's evidence and accepting the plaintiff's, which they argued was "glaringly improbable".
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Former snooker world champion Graeme Dott jailed for child sexual abuseDott, 49, receives seven-year sentence after abusing a boy and a girl in what judge says was ‘gross violation of trust’
Read more »
‘Love us or hate us’: MKR’s Alisha and Deanne refuse to back down after explosive walkoutThe feisty team from South Australia accused judge Colin Fassnidge of taking sides, but the chef has his own piece of advice for the mums.
Read more »
England Cricket Teams Rebounding and Refining Under New ManagementStephen Fleming and Joe Root lead England's resurgence with a mature approach after recent struggles.
Read more »
Judge recuses himself in Rohan Dennis case of driving while disqualifiedA new sentencing judge will hear a case against former Olympic cyclist Rohan Dennis, who has pleaded guilty to driving while disqualified.
Read more »