A decade-old review of the Cbus superannuation fund reveals concerns about governance and the influence of the CFMEU. The review, conducted in 2015, recommended appointing more independent directors to the board to curb the union's power and improve the fund's culture. Despite the recommendations, concerns remain about the fund's relationship with the CFMEU.
A decade-old secret review examining a governance scandal at industry superannuation giant Cbus recommended appointing more independent directors to its board to curb the powerful influence of the CFMEU and improve the fund’s culture.
Former competition tsar Graeme Samuel, who led the 2015 review, found the composition of the Cbus board at the time – made up of employer and union representatives – created a culture of “proprietorship” that at times turned a blind eye to members’ personal information being leaked to the construction union. The review, released on Monday, was commissioned by Cbus’ then chair, Steve Bracks, a former Victorian Labor premier, to examine governance failures at the fund after two employees were found to have leaked information about fund members to the CFMEU, which was campaigning against Lis-Con Concrete Constructions over the company’s alleged late payments of superannuation.Samuel found that Cbus, which has assets of more than $100 billion, relied too heavily on the CFMEU to act as a bulwark against employers breaking the law by not paying their staff their superannuation entitlements on time, and the fund would benefit from more independent directors. “This creates a culture of proprietorship of the organisation by the sponsor members, and that proprietorship culture permeates through to impact in varying ways on those dealing with the organisation and in particular its employees,” Samuel said in the review. He added that while Cbus’ culture was driven to deliver the best outcomes for members, it also left the super fund exposed to the risk of being too reliant on the CFMEU and seemingly working in the union’s interest. “On the one hand, this culture produces strong commitment to the interests of Cbus members. On the other hand, this culture, if misdirected, can lead to attitudes on the part of employees that gives rise to an acceptance of the propriety of practices such as those that are the subject of this review.” Samuel said the culture and governance of Cbus would improve if there were more independent directors with relevant experience on the board. At the time, there was only one independent director, former Labor treasurer John Dawkins.The two independent directors currently on the board are Wayne Swan, who is a former Labor treasurer and current Labor president, and John Edwards, a former Reserve Bank of Australia board member. The Australian Council of Trade Unions no longer has a say on the appointment of the chair, who is currently Swan, following Samuel’s recommendations. The remaining 11 positions on the board are split between employer organisation Master Builders Australia, and unions the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union, the Communications, Electrical and Plumbing Union, and the CFMEU. “The reviewers are not of the opinion Cbus would necessarily benefit from a majority of independent directors and would not be making that recommendation,” the review noted. “However, the appointment of additional independent directors with the expertise and ability to properly present independent views to the board is seen to be of advantage in the future governance of Cbus both internally and in its dealings with external parties in relation to its ongoing business strategy.” The Senate released the secret review on Monday following a push by Liberal MP Andrew Bragg last year to force the financial regulator to produce the report. The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) baulked at the time, citing secrecy clauses. “The report makes clear the governance standards at Cbus were as broken then as they are now,” Bragg said. “Samuel makes the case for independent directors and a stronger conflicts framework … It appears no progress has been made in a decade. The government seems uninterested at best and seems unwilling to make improvements for consumers.
Cbus Superannuation Governance CFMEU Independent Directors Review APRA Senate
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Corporate cop enters into mediation with embattled CbusThe construction sector superannuation fund has avoided a potentially protracted courtroom showdown that would have brought further scrutiny on its failure to promptly process the insurance claims of thousands of members.
Read more »
Corporate cop enters into mediation with embattled CbusThe construction sector superannuation fund has avoided a potentially protracted courtroom showdown that would have brought further scrutiny on its failure to promptly process the insurance claims of thousands of members.
Read more »
Corporate cop enters into mediation with embattled CbusThe construction sector superannuation fund has avoided a potentially protracted courtroom showdown that would have brought further scrutiny on its failure to promptly process the insurance claims of thousands of members.
Read more »
Union Boss Denies Misusing Super Fund Position to Benefit CFMEUMichael O’Connor, a long-serving union secretary, has denied allegations that he misused his position as co-chair of a $4.5 billion superannuation fund to support the financially struggling manufacturing division of the CFMEU. APRA is suing O’Connor for allegedly appointing a union delegate to a full-time role at First Super while they continued to work for the CFMEU. O'Connor maintains he recused himself from board discussions regarding the contract extension and denies any wrongdoing.
Read more »
Psychiatrist Accuses Government of Stacking Gender-Affirming Care Review with Trans ActivistsA leading child and adolescent psychiatrist has criticized the Australian government for stacking a review into gender-affirming care for minors with transgender activists, alleging it's an attempt to receive desired advice. Dr. Jillian Spencer questioned the review's integrity and necessity, particularly given the 2024 Cass Review's publication, which spurred the UK to ban puberty blockers for children. The government faces criticism for potentially using the review to stall a ban on puberty blockers, while Transcend Australia, a transgender support organization, advocates for continued access to gender-affirming healthcare.
Read more »
Hitler’s ‘English girlfriend’ says she was bullied by Goebbels because she didn’t like MussoliniThe revelation follows the discovery of secret diaries from British socialite Unity Mitford.
Read more »