The Supreme Court agreed Monday to finally decide whether rights to a unanimous jury verdict and an insanity defense are constitutional requirements that apply nationwide.
Most states, but not all, permit criminal defendants to plead insanity and escape the full punishment of the law on the grounds that they did not know right from wrong at the time of the crime. Kansas says defendants may cite a “mental disease or defect” as a defense, but they may be found guilty nonetheless if they intended to commit a violent crime.from James Kahler, who shot and killed two of his daughters, his ex-wife and her grandmother, and sought to plead insanity.
But a state expert testified that Kahler planned the murders. He was convicted and sentenced to death, despite his insanity plea.argues that the insanity defense is a fundamental aspect of American justice and cannot be restricted or abolished by the states. His lawyers said Alaska, Montana, Idaho and Utah also limited the use of insanity as a defense to a crime.
The justices will also hear the case of Ramos vs. Louisiana to decide whether a jury must be unanimous to hand down a guilty verdict.convicted Evangelisto Ramos, by a 10-2 vote, of murdering a prostitute. The state has since adopted a requirement of unanimous juries beginning this year, but the court will decide whether this is a constitutional requirement. Only Oregon continues to permit verdicts where the jury is not unanimous.
In a third criminal case, the justices will decide whether Lee Boyd Malvo will serve life in prison for his role in the 2002 sniper shootings in the Washington area. John Allen Muhammad was convicted of the shootings and was executed in Virginia for his crimes. Malvo, who was then 17, was sentenced to life in prison with no chance for parole.
The Supreme Court later put new limits on life prison terms for those who commit murders as a juvenile, and the court in Mathena vs. Malvo will decide whether those rulings apply retroactively to those already serving life terms.
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
2020 Candidates float plans to change Supreme CourtAre changes to the Supreme Court on the horizon? chucktodd looks at some of the ideas that 2020 presidential candidates have been considering.
Read more »
An Appeals Court Ruled For The First Time That Trump Can Be Sued In State Court'Though he is tasked with significant responsibilities, the President is still a person, and he is not above the law.'
Read more »
Trump Court Pick Neomi Rao Confirmed As Kavanaugh’s Appeals Court ReplacementWASHINGTON ― A woman who blamed women for date rape will now fill BrettKavanaugh's former U
Read more »
Petrobras asks to participate in Supreme Court case on state divestmentsBrazilian state-run oil firm Petroleo Brasileiro SA has formally requested the r...
Read more »
Mexico Senate picks wife of president's business ally for Supreme CourtMexico's Senate on Tuesday chose the wife of a business ally of President A...
Read more »
Sandy Hook families can sue gunmaker Remington -Connecticut courtThe Connecticut Supreme Court on Thursday allowed families who lost loved ones i...
Read more »
Connecticut Supreme Court rules gunmaker can be sued over Sandy Hook shootingGun maker Remington can be sued over how it marketed the Bushmaster rifle used to kill 20 children and six educators at Sandy Hook Elementary School in 2012, a divided Connecticut Supreme Court ruled Thursday.
Read more »
Opinion | How the Supreme Court weakened Congress on emergency declarationsTo understand how a 1983 Supreme Court decision dramatically affected the way the government works, consider what Congress had intended when it passed the National Emergencies Act.
Read more »
CT Supreme Court Decision Allows Sandy Hook Suit to Go OnGun maker Remington can be sued over how it marketed the Bushmaster rifle used to kill 20 children and six educators at Sandy Hook Elementary School in 2012, a divided Connecticut Supreme Court ruled Thursday.
Read more »