A global poll of 24,000 respondents reveals Sydney's ranking, while comparing its strengths and weaknesses against Melbourne, highlighting factors like infrastructure, geography, culture, and political climate. Melbourne is frequently ranked above Sydney in other indexes.
global poll of 24,000 respondents. Now should be the moment for a staunch defence of Sydney – how about that Metro! – or at least some condescending remarks about weather, beaches, and younger siblings with a chip on their shoulder.
Sydney is ranked 21, but we couldn’t be bothered trying too hard, as long as we’re ahead of Paris.methodology. Adelaide ahead of Amsterdam? Only one Italian city in the top 50, and it’s Naples? Only one French city? Marrakech in the top 25, when it’s not even the best city in Morocco? Two Brazilian cities, Rio de Janeiro and Sao Paolo, ahead of Sydney, when Brazil’s biggest export to Sydney is its people?Global Liveability Index, a more systematic attempt to rate cities based on stability, healthcare, culture, environment, education and infrastructure, has ranked Melbourne ahead of Sydney in each year it has run. The Oxford Global Cities Index, which is serious enough to place New York, London and Paris as its top three, rates Melbourne above Sydney. The evidence is pretty much in. To be fair, if you took away Sydney’s sumptuous geography, its waterways and mountains and coastline, Melbourne does crap all over us a little bit. Its physical flatness and grid design have spread its advantages more democratically, whereas Sydney’s topographic variety has sharpened inequality.and quirky galleries,” it reports. “And don’t let anyone tell you Melbourne is all personality over looks – we’ve got grand,and a river that holds deep spiritual and cultural significance for local Indigenous communities.” And thanks to its progressive politics, Melbourne is always the target of far-right social media bots showing a multicultural road to hell. So that’s another thing it’s got going for it.Melbourne also has a new Metro, which works. And its attractions are in easy reach, unlike Sydney, where, for example, we have a brand-new fish market that you can access from the CBD via a half-hour trudge over confusing footbridges, under concrete overpasses, and through the gauntlet of shared cycleways, and when you get there, good luck finding a table and chair to eat at. Both cities carry the DNA of their foundation. Melbourne was built by free settlers; Sydney by prisoners. Melbourne was planned. Sydney, for 238 years, has just happened. Does it have to be a competition? Well, no, but yes. Competition, while tiresome, benefits all. Unless it’s the American version of competition, which is for Washington DC to send militias to shoot people in cities that didn’t vote for Donald Trump. Eye-catchingly, New York was the only US city to crackdamns Sydney with faint praise. “Sydneysiders are also third-most likely to call their city ‘beautiful’, with 78 per cent of locals describing it as such.” That is, we’re proud of our dumb luck. The next best thing going for Sydney? “With about 40 per cent of the city’s population having been born overseas,span every cuisine and meals are executed with finesse.” This is about as insightful as Angus Taylor defining “good immigration” by the standards of a cappuccino he once had in Cooma. Against the actual lived experience of Sydneysiders – traffic gridlock, unreliable public transport and vast disparities in access to healthcare, education and affordable housing – it’s not a whole lot to go on. What Sydney does have going for it, however, is what Australia has going for it: it’s not too proud to borrow from elsewhere. Looking down the list of the world’s best cities, it is tempting to imagine a conglomerate, a Frankencity put together shamelessly from importation and imitation. How good would Sydney be if you could pick up inner Melbourne and plonk it beside the harbour?The bowerbird impulse has made Sydney what it is. Copenhagen might beat Sydney in every liveability survey, but the world’s greatest work of Danish architecture sits on Bennelong Point. The jacaranda tree is native to cities like Buenos Aires but since 1850 its most vivid glories are in Sydney. Green spaces in cities don’t come better than New York’s Central Park, but the Domain, Hyde Park, Centennial Park and Barangaroo are among a vast network of Sydney’s “lungs” that activists have fought to preserve and expand. The last great Victorian-Edwardian sports pavilions are not in London but in. Tokyo and Seoul might lead the world in social courtesy, but in Sydney the utter dickheads are still rare enough that they stand out from the crowd. Just. I might be forcing it now.With so much of the world in flames literal or figurative, city rankings give us a chance to see the glass as half-full. In thesurvey, Melbourne and Sydney ranked highly in locals agreeing with the statements “My city makes me happy” and “I find joy in the everyday experiences where I live”. Personally, I find joy in the Norfolk Island pines I see when I walk my dog. I find joy in other dogs. I find joy in the always-smiling crossing guard at the local primary school, and in the intense efficiency of the man who controls the queuing system at the grocery store. I find joy in the Harbour Bridge, even if I only look at it once every so often. It makes me happy to know it’s there. “If you’re living in Australia, and you’re not in Sydney, you’re camping out.” Paul Keating denies he spoke these words, though stealing them would be a very Sydney thing to do. Instead, in a 1995 radio interview in which he disclaimed the quote, he said, “The people have taken the natural topography and made something of it. If I look at Sydney, where I’m from, where there has always been that great advantage of the Harbour, which is the natural asset the city had, Sydney has never done as much with the rest of the place as the people of Melbourne have done with Melbourne. You can see vista upon vista here of cityscapes, and really particularly suburb development, and suburb and views, they are by and large superior to most of Australia’s cities.”Malcolm Knox is a journalist, author and regular columnist.
Sydney Melbourne Liveability Global Rankings Infrastructure
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Melbourne Aged Care Home Fined $150,000 Over Deadly COVID-19 Outbreak, Families OutragedSt Basil’s Homes for the Aged in Melbourne was fined $150,000 after pleading guilty to failing to provide a safe working environment during a deadly COVID-19 outbreak. Families of the 45 residents who died in the outbreak expressed outrage, calling the fine an insult.
Read more »
Women tell court Barry Cable sexually assaulted them as children in Melbourne backyard spasFormer footballer Barry Cable sexually assaulted children in a backyard spa in Melbourne at a time when he was a 'famous' figure, a court has heard.
Read more »
Melbourne Crowned World's Best City for 2026 by Global Lifestyle Media BrandMelbourne has been named the best city in the world for 2026 by a global lifestyle media brand, surpassing London and New York. The city's high ranking is based on a survey of residents and expert opinions, emphasizing its diversity, vibrancy, and cultural offerings. Sydney and Adelaide also made the list, ranking at number 21 and 29 respectively.
Read more »
Melbourne's Suburban Rail Loop makes Australia's top infrastructure body's priority listAustralia's top infrastructure body has placed Melbourne's Suburban Rail Loop project on the highest priority list for the nation despite raising serious concerns about its business case merely a year ago.
Read more »
Melbourne Crowned World's Best City for 2026Melbourne has been named the best city in the world for 2026 by a global lifestyle media brand, topping London, New York and others due to its diversity, vibrancy, and cultural scene. The ranking, based on a survey and expert panel, saw Melbourne climb from fourth place last year. Locals and visitors offered varied perspectives, with many praising the city's balanced lifestyle and affordability.
Read more »
Melbourne Crowned World's Best City: Is It 'Vibes' Over Substance?Melbourne takes the top spot in Time Out's 50 Best Cities list for 2026, lauded for its food, culture, and arts. However, the ranking's reliance on subjective assessments prompts debate regarding the methodology's validity in comparison to alternative city ranking systems.
Read more »