+34
The Greens have installed David Shoebridge as leader, who pledges to replace Labor rather than work with it, as economic pressures and One Nation gains leave Labor vulnerable.
The Greens have installed David Shoebridge as their new leader, a move that could mark an inflection point for Labor if it suffers a shock catastrophe at the next federal election.
Shoebridge has pledged to replace Labor, not reform it or work with it. He blamed Labor for the rise of One Nation, declared war on the 1 per cent and lambasted incremental politics. Things have been going south for Labor for a while. Polling numbers for the government and for Anthony Albanese have declined, with the former most recently hitting the party's lowest point since 2012.
One Nation's support is now baked in and is beginning to nibble away at Labor's margins, having already sacked the Coalition's fortresses. When it comes to actual seats in parliament, Labor has found itself in a protective cocoon of sorts. If the events of this week play out a certain way, that cocoon could be vulnerable.
Interest Rates And One Nation Advances
Interest rates reached a 15-year high this week, followed by still-high inflation figures that raise the very real prospect of another rate rise in November. All this compounds the economic pain of this era, perhaps sends things to a tipping point, making the time ripe for further One Nation advances. But the wildcard, the thing that sets this week apart, is on Labor's other political flank, where the Greens installed Shoebridge as leader.
David Shoebridge is one of parliament's best operators. We don't talk much about the Greens these days, which itself is telling. These are meant to be times of economic hardship and political upheaval, of the major parties in disrepute and the people in revolt. In France, often polling in second place after the far right is the New Popular Front, a coalition of communists, socialists and environmentalists.
In the United Kingdom, the Greens roughly doubled their vote in the past two years before receding through the middle of this year. In the United States, the signal case is Zohran Mamdani, whose ascent to New York mayor presaged a suite of victories in Democrat primaries by democratic socialists and fellow travellers. But here? Where is the green wave?
Green Party Strategy Under Waters
One explanation for its absence is that under Waters, the Greens have been too quietist. Too conciliatory. Too constructive. In that view, Waters might be able to point to certain legislative achievements on investor taxes, on national environmental laws, on native forest protections, but she never grabbed us by the throat.
This complaint often overlooks what came before: specifically that the Greens took hard lines and ran sustained campaigns on economically populist ideas, such as rent freezes, throughout the last term. They did this in a cost of living crisis and persisted right through a cost of living election.
Then they lost all but one of their lower-house seats. Their most pugnacious performer, Max Chandler-Mather, who led the charge on housing, lost his seat of Griffith. Waters, then, was a response. A doer, not a blocker.
I suppose it's possible they got this strategy exactly wrong. That they were obstructionist when people wanted solutions, and constructive when they wanted revolt: that the Greens zigged when they should have zagged. Certainly, that seems to be Shoebridge's view. His opening salvo has been to pledge to replace Labor, not reform or work with it.
Shoebridge Radical Approach To Labor
He blamed Labor for the rise of One Nation. He declared war on the 1 per cent and lambasted incremental politics. That's self-consciously radical. He didn't mention Mamdani, but he was certainly evoking him.
There are dangers in extending the Mamdani example too far. Mamdani seems a generational talent: an insurgent, perhaps, but an extremely charming and likeable one. Unlike the Greens, he is a fresh new face, not a familiar one. He comes with no accumulated baggage, no hardened impressions.
Also unlike the Greens, he is attempting to remake a party of government from within, not displace it from without. And again, unlike the Greens, Mamdani arrived with Donald Trump at the levers of power, not One Nation sitting entirely outside of it. The Australian multi-party situation doesn't map easily onto the American one, but if we must draw parallels, it's more like when an unpopular Biden administration was in charge.
Polanski And The Green Movement Challenge
And in that period, the democratic socialist movement was idling, not surging. The better analogue for Shoebridge is not Mamdani, but British Greens leader Zack Polanski. His rise was pronounced, but off a very low base. Now, he seems to have bumped his head on a ceiling roughly where the Australian Greens are.
Polanski had the advantage of being a new quantity, not a known one. As he has become more known, gravity has taken hold. And perhaps that points to the Greens' greatest challenge: that in an anti-establishment moment, they come across as part of the establishment. They signed agreements with prime minister Julia Gillard, helped install a carbon tax and currently hold the balance of power in the Senate again.
When they behave moderately, they are part of the system. When they behave radically, they are obstructing things. One Nation, meanwhile, has the luxury of having never been the powerbroker, which means it can sound off as it likes while obstructing nothing. It promises a cleansing fire, not gridlock.
I suspect that's what leads Shoebridge to talk of replacement. His plea is for power, not the balance of it. Replace Labor, and you're acting, not obstructing. It's an enormous, unlikely ask.
It might fail spectacularly, in which case Labor probably survives in some battered way. But Labor will be nervous. The orange wave is turbulent enough, but it's survivable as long as it crashes on the walls of our cities. This week's economic news increases the chances it might finally breach those walls from one side.
And if the week's political developments cause a green wave to swell, too, Labor might find itself inundated.
brisbanetimes
smh:This story was compiled and edited by the HeadTopics newsroom and HT AI from the reports above.
David Shoebridge Australian Politics One Nation Labor Government
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
David Shoebridge Elected Greens Leader Pledges To Replace LaborDavid Shoebridge has been elected leader of the Australian Greens in a rare contested vote, defeating Mehreen Faruqi and Sarah Hanson-Young, and vows a tougher approach to Labor.
Read more »
David Shoebridge Becomes Greens Leader, Vows Red Hot Fight Against Elite 1% and One NationDavid Shoebridge has been elected federal leader of the Australian Greens after Larissa Waters' resignation, promising a red hot fight for voters and a member vote on future leaders.
Read more »
David Shoebridge Elected Greens Leader With a Populist Left StrategyDavid Shoebridge's elevation to the Greens leadership signals a strategic shift toward populist left-wing politics, stronger cost-of-living campaigning and greater competition with Labor in inner-city electorates. His hard-line rhetoric, closeness to the party's left wing and plans for an assertive economic agenda could reshape the party's direction ahead of the next federal election.
Read more »
Labor MP Accuses Greens Leader Shoebridge of Prejudice Against Jewish AustraliansLabor MP Josh Burns accused new Greens leader David Shoebridge of prejudice after he said his party has strong ties with Jewish Australians fighting a genocide. The dispute follows Shoebridge's election to replace Larissa Waters.
Read more »