Let’s not draw the wrong conclusions from Hungary’s election or the US president’s troubles, says political scientist Cas Mudde
Hungary's Petér Magyar, who will be sworn in as prime minister on 9 May, speaks at the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, earlier this month.
decline of the far rightFirst, as far as lessons for how to defeat so-called illiberal democrats are concerned, we must bear in mind that Orbán was in power for an exceptionally rare 16 years. This allowed him to oversee not only a political transformation of Hungary, but an economic and societal one.
His defeat was not a rejection of his far-right policies, certainly not his anti-immigration policies , but of the country’s dire economic situation and the allegations of massive Victory for Magyar, who will be sworn in on 9 May, was not so much an endorsement of his policies, but a consequence of his tireless campaigning outside the traditional opposition strongholds in the most strategic constituencies in an extremely disproportional electoral system. While this strategy could pay off in similar ways in majoritarian systems such as France, the UK and the US, it would be much less impactful in proportional systems such as the Netherlands.
Still, asSecond, while the European far right has lost its unofficial leader, it is not in decline. Sure, some other far-right parties have also recently lost elections or power . But far-right parties remain in government in a variety of EU member states , and lead the polls in several others .
The thing is, the far right is here to stay, and many of its parties are as established as the “mainstream” parties. And, like other parties, their electoral support fluctuates and is affected by internal and external factors, such as corruption, infighting and crises in government. More importantly, the mainstreaming and normalisation of far-right actors and ideas continue unabated.
Giorgia Meloni’s Italy has become a mandatory pilgrimage site for politicians who try to present themselves as tough on immigration – from the European Commission president,, the EU-wide political alliance of centre-right parties, is now openly collaborating with far-right parties to pass legislation in the European parliament, while still openly And this collaboration is not limited to immigration. As long ago as the 2024 EU elections, the EPP was adopting far-right scepticism towards the climate crisis and environmental protection, in an effort to keep dissatisfied farmers from jumping ship to the far right.
” for the far right, although this had no significant effect on the Hungarian election. But this toxicity issue is not static. Simply stated, when the US president is threatening to occupy Greenland and leave Nato, or introducing trade tariffs on the EU, he is a liability for European far-right parties.
But when he is mainly linked to anti-establishment and immigration policies, or his alleged fight against “the swamp” and “wokeness”, his star rises again within the far right – althoughBut Trump helps the European far right simply by being the US president. Because whenever the president of the most powerful country in the world says something, it is by definition not politically marginal.
Moreover, much of what he says, however extreme, is normalised and rationalised in the discourse of mainstream media and politicians – just look at the obsequiousness of the Nato secretary general,behaviour is so extreme and often seems unhinged, it is very easy for European far-right leaders to seem “moderate” in comparison – after all, he or she is “not as bad as Trump”. This endless comparison, and the inability to accept that there can be various shades of far right, helps savvy politicians such as Meloni.
By not acting aggressively, erratically and loudly like Trump , she is mistaken for a mere “conservative” rather than a radical-right politician. She is thereby also helped by theAll of this is not to take anything away from Magyar or from the wonderful Hungarian people who opposed and ousted Orbán – and particularly the many leftwing Hungarians who voted for a rightwing politician to save democracy.
It is also not to deny the symbolic significance of Orbán’s defeat. We should very much celebrate this important victory. But we should do so without generalising and simplifying, so we can ensure that similar election victories can be achieved in Europe and the US. Cas Mudde is the Stanley Wade Shelton UGAF professor of international affairs at the University of Georgia, and author of The Far Right Today
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Trump tries to downplay economic effects of the Iran warAs the president tries to wrench the focus back to measures to help small business, the economic alarm bells from the spiralling Iran war are ringing ever louder.
Read more »
Trump tries to downplay economic effects of the Iran warAs the president tries to wrench the focus back to measures to help small business, the economic alarm bells from the spiralling Iran war are ringing ever louder.
Read more »
Trump Highlights Small Business Gains Amid Economic Fallout from Iran WarPresident Donald Trump touted economic wins for small businesses while downplaying rising energy costs due to his war with Iran, which has driven up oil prices and gas costs for Americans.
Read more »
Trump turns up the volume on economic wins and acing his testsThe US president says the economy is “roaring” despite the fallout from the Iran war making things more expensive. And delivering a focused message on the economy is not much in Trump’s style.
Read more »
Trump turns up the volume on economic wins and acing his testsThe US president says the economy is “roaring” despite the fallout from the Iran war making things more expensive. And delivering a focused message on the economy is not much in Trump’s style.
Read more »
Grim, worse and dire: the three ways Donald Trump is playing havoc with Reserve Bank forecastsDonald Trump is not living rent-free in the heads of central bankers. He’s ratching up rents like the New York property tycoon he was, creating pandemonium and pain.
Read more »