+34
It follows the rejection of his appeal to bring a case of genocide personally against King Charles.
The Victorian Supreme Court has rejected an appeal by Uncle Robbie Thorpe against a decision to block his attempt to prosecute King Charles III for genocide.
The Krauatatungalung Elder first brought the case in 2023, lodging a private prosecution in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria that accused the King of committing, and continuing to commit, genocide against Australia's First Peoples. A senior registrar refused to issue the proceeding, finding it would be an abuse of process. A judge later upheld that decision, with the latest ruling dismissing Uncle Robbie's appeal.
"What we're doing is demonstrating the fact that Australia is unwilling, unable, reluctant to deal with these issues ... and we're educating the people along the way," he said. "Most people are completely ignorant about the true history here. People don't realise the gravity of crimes. We call it crime scene Australia.
"Uncle Robbie's case relied partly on First Peoples' law, which he says has never been displaced because sovereignty was never ceded. The judge declined to proceed because she found the Magistrates' Court had no power to hear the case. According to the appeal judgement, she acknowledged that Uncle Robbie had made "a strong argument" that Australia's First Peoples had never ceded sovereignty and that their laws continued in force.
However, "there was nothing conferred jurisdiction on the Magistrates' Court to deal with criminal offences under the sovereign laws of Australia's First Peoples.
" The court can only hear cases that Parliament has given it the power to hear, and the judge found no law that did so for First Peoples' law. On the common law, she said earlier decisions, including two cases Uncle Robbie was involved in, had found genocide cannot be prosecuted in Australian courts without specific legislation. As a single judge, she was bound by those decisions.
On the Criminal Code, which does make genocide an offence, she noted that a prosecution needs the written consent of the Commonwealth Attorney-General. That had not been obtained, so issuing the case would have been an abuse of process. Some critics, such as Independent Senator Lidia Thorpe, have interpreted the need for politicial approval before proceeding with cases of genocide as obstructing articles I and V of the UN's genocide convention.
A proposed amendment to the criminal code by Thorpe, which would have removed the attorney general's veto, was voted down in the senate in 2025.
"It's up to the ... attorney general to decide whether genocide cases can ," said Uncle Robbie. Uncle Robbie says the plan was always to move through the domestic options first. The Elder believes the Australian system is "institutionally racist", and that the hope going forward lies in international mechanisms.
"By exhausting the domestic potential remedies" he intends to go "to the International Criminal Court or the International Court of Justice", he said. "We're appealing to any country around the world to take us to the ... we're never going to see justice in these courts here. " Genocide can be prosecuted internationally, but the processes differ. Cases at the International Court of Justice must be brought by one state against another.
"So the current most high-profile example of that is, of course, South Africa versus Israel, in which South Africa, of course, has alleged Israel has breached the Genocide Convention as a result of its conduct in Gaza," he said. Professor Rothwell said the Rome Statute allows individuals to alert the court to alleged crimes, which "effectively invites the court to commence an investigation, and that investigation would be conducted by the Office of the Prosecutor, the OTP".
"It would be fair to say that the Office of the Prosecutor has been overwhelmed by these types of applications that have been made over the last 24 years ... And obviously, some will have greater merit than others.
"But the critical question is capacity. Does the International Criminal Court have capacity to investigate all of these particular matters?
" he said. He pointed to Senator Jacqui Lambie, who has brought the conduct of senior Australian military personnel to the court's attention.
"It's a well-established procedure, but the chances of success are relatively low," Professor Rothwell said. "Often ... using these processes gains a lot of traction, a lot of momentum, a lot of international attention to these types of matters, irrespective of whether or not they fail on some of the legal hurdles that are up in that line," he said.
"We're appealing to any country around the world to take us to the International Criminal Court because we're not members," he said. ShareReceive the latest Indigenous news, sport, entertainment and more in your email inbox.
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Australia inflation rises amid global tensions and technology safety concernsAustralia's Consumer Price Index rose 4 per cent in the year to August, with housing identified as the largest contributor. Qatar reported continued mediation efforts between the United States and Iran amid fears of regional escalation. Australia also announced new grants to address online technology abuse, particularly violence against women and the spread of manosphere content. Separately, Saudi King Mohammed appointed Fatima Zahra El Mansouri as the kingdom's first female prime minister and urban planning minister.
Read more »
Vodafone launches Australia's first 48-month phone repayment planVodafone becomes the first Australian telco to offer a four-year interest-free device repayment plan, halving monthly handset costs as phone prices exceed $5000, but consumer advocates warn of risks.
Read more »
Australia's Big Four Banks to Pass on RBA Rate Hike, Boosting Mortgage CostsAustralia's major banks are expected to fully pass on the Reserve Bank's 0.25 percentage point interest rate increase, adding approximately $122 to monthly repayments on an $800,000 mortgage. While Macquarie Bank has already announced the change, data indicates that offset account balances remain near record highs and delinquency rates for home loans stay low, suggesting households are currently cushioned against the financial strain.
Read more »
Margot Robbie Takes Husband Tom Ackerley's Surname After a Decade of MarriageAfter ten years of marriage, Margot Robbie has changed her surname to that of her husband, Tom Ackerley, prompting renewed discussion about the expectation that women who marry men should take their husband's name.
Read more »