As TikTok faces a potential ban in the US, many users are flocking to Xiaohongshu, a Chinese social media app. While this presents an opportunity for cross-cultural connection, the app's strict censorship policies, particularly its struggle with English content moderation, raise concerns about free expression and the potential for self-censorship among users.
When Angelica Oung received the notification that her Xiaohongshu account had been blocked for violating the social media app’s code of conduct, her mind started racing. The only picture she had posted on her account, apart from her profile headshot, was of herself wearing an inflatable polar bear suit, holding a sign saying: “I love nuclear”. What could be the problem with that, wondered Oung, a clean energy activist in Taiwan.
Was it because, at a glance, her picture looked like someone holding a placard at a protest? Was it because her costume looked a bit like the white hazmat suits worn by China’s Covid prevention workers during the pandemic, who became a widely reviled symbol of the lockdown? Or was it because in the background was Taipei 101, Taiwan’s iconic skyscraper? Oung never found out. “It is really opaque,” she said. “My theory is that Xiaohongshu just got slammed with so many new accounts.” last week, according to Reuters. “TikTok refugees” have fled to the app, also known as RedNote, as TikTok faces being banned in the US on 19 January if it does not divest from its Chinese parent company, ByteDance., which has more than 170million American users. Founded in 2013 as an online community focused on shopping and travel tips, the Shanghai-based Xiaohongshu has more than 300million, predominantly female, users. It is reportedly valued at $17bn. The surge of new users it is experiencing has forced Xiaohongshu’s moderators to scramble to keep the content on the platform in line with Beijing’s censorship requirements. Unlike TikTok, which is an international subsidiary and has a sister app for Chinese users, Xiaohongshu is a purely Chinese operation. TikTok’s detractors argue that it is a danger to national security because the users’ data is at risk of being compromised by China. Some lawmakers have also raised concerns that the content on the platform is manipulated to suit Beijing’s interests.But fearful of losing access to their favourite app – and perhaps just jumping on a new trend – users have defied the lawmakers’ concerns about the Chinese Communist party and flocked to another Chinese platform. Like all Chinese social media, Xiaohongshu’s content is strictly censored in line with Beijing’s laws, which prohibits content deemed counter to the government’s interests.But its existing guidelines are for Chinese-language content. This week, the hashtag “Red Note is urgently recruiting English content moderators” trended on Weibo, andhave been appearing on recruitment websites. Chinese officials have reportedly told the company to ensure that China-based users can’t see posts from US users. While Chinese internet users are adept at finding their ways round censorship, they are also used to self-censorship, avoiding certain topics that could get them blocked. On Xiaohongshu, they have tips for the American newcomers. “DON’T mention sensitive topics,” counselled a lifestyle influencer. “Don’t talk about religion or politics,” said one British user in China, who said he has been posting on the platform for five years.Christine Lu, an entrepreneur based in Los Angeles, was also blocked from Xiaohongshu last week. As a test of the app’s censors, she had posted pictures that featured the Tibetan flag and the Taiwan flag – both topics that are considered “sensitive” in China. “As suspected, it’s going to be impossible to have fully self-expressed conversations with Chinese people in China via this app,” Lu said on X. Eric Liu, a former content moderator for Weibo, said: “It is still very difficult for Chinese internet companies to conduct English censorship … censors mainly rely on the understanding of China’s political correctness that is cultivated in school and in ideological and political courses … you can’t just rely on translation software”.Liu said that Xiaohongshu’s lack of English-language capacity meant that censorship was likely to be “rough and indiscriminate … giving priority to satisfying the requirements of the authorities”. The censorship, and banning of users, may pour cold water on the idea that the app could be a place for Chinese and US internet users to communicate and share jokes and memes. “I do think it is an unalloyed good that people who are in countries that are geopolitically at odds, and perhaps for good reason, just get to connect with each other,” said Oung.She says: “It’s a really interesting test of whether the Chinese government feels confident enough to actually let it continue”. Chenchen Zhang, an assistant professor at Durham University, said that the current enthusiasm for the uniting power of social media is a “surreal” throwback to the utopian ideals of the internet in the 1990s
Social Media Xiaohongshu Tiktok Censorship Social Media US China Relations Internet Freedom
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
TikTok and the Rise of Medical MisinformationA doctor shares their experiences with the increasing impact of medical misinformation spread through platforms like TikTok.
Read more »
The rise and rise of Maye Musk: China’s love affair with Elon Musk’s motherThe 76-year-old is part of a trend of ‘silver influencers’ whose success in the face of adversity resonates strongly. Could she be Elon’s secret weapon in China?
Read more »
TikTok Ban Looms: Influencers Flock to RedNote and Lemon8As a potential US shutdown of TikTok approaches, influencers and users are seeking alternatives, driving RedNote and Lemon8 to the top of Apple's download charts. The Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversaries Controlled Applications Act, set to come into effect before Trump's inauguration, aims to force TikTok's sale of its US operations or face a ban due to national security concerns. While TikTok's parent company ByteDance insists it won't sell, users are preparing for the app's potential shutdown, with the term 'TikTok refugee' trending on RedNote, a Chinese social media app similar to Instagram. Another contender, Lemon8, is also owned by ByteDance and seen as a backup for TikTok. The US Supreme Court is expected to uphold the law banning TikTok, prompting a shift towards platforms like YouTube and Instagram.
Read more »
Inside Syria's State News Agency: A Decade of Censorship and FearThis article sheds light on the oppressive working conditions within Syria's state news agency, Sana, under the Assad regime. Journalists faced severe consequences, including arbitrary arrests and detention, for even minor reporting errors or perceived dissent. The article highlights personal accounts of journalists who endured censorship and fear for years, emphasizing the chilling impact of the regime's control over information.
Read more »
Crocodile Dundee Edits Spark Debate On Censorship and Cultural SensitivityChannel 5's broadcast of Crocodile Dundee sparked controversy due to edits made to the film's content, particularly the removal of scenes deemed potentially offensive by some viewers. This decision has ignited debate about the right of broadcasters to alter films for their audience and the impact of cultural sensitivities on classic comedies.
Read more »
Al Jazeera Suspended in West Bank, Accuses PA of Mimicking Israeli CensorshipAl Jazeera, a prominent Middle East broadcaster, has been suspended from operating in the West Bank by the Palestinian Authority (PA). The PA accuses Al Jazeera of biased reporting and incitement, while Al Jazeera claims the suspension resembles Israeli censorship practices.
Read more »