This article reviews Peter Beinart's book exploring the complexities of the Israel-Palestine conflict in the aftermath of Hamas's attacks on October 7, 2023. Beinart emphasizes the need for empathy, understanding, and open debate within the Jewish community, urging a move away from silencing dissent and a recognition that support for Israel is not synonymous with Jewish identity.
murderous attacks by Hamas on October 7, 2023. This human suffering is immeasurable – and it has had a dramatic effect on the Jewish community across the world, tearing friends and family apart. Can you be a community that for centuries has experienced persecution and victimhood but turns away when asked to account for violence in your name?is brilliant, painful. Brilliant because of the scholarly way Beinart approaches the complexity of the issues.
“In families where there is a disagreement, people are able to put that aside because there is an investment in the relationship,” he said. “Those who are deeply divided can try to find ways of engaging with the subject that involve empathy for one another. I try to express an understanding of the perspectives of those people who are in a different place than I am.”And when might this reconciliation take place? “Perhaps as we move further away from the trauma of October 7,” he says.
“I hear it used all the time. It is one of the stupidest phrases,” Beinart says. To acknowledge that Israel is murdering Palestinians is not a libel. “There is a basis in reality,” he says.That form of silencing is also used to stifle debate at universities. In the past year in Australia alone, there have been dozens of instances of universities being called upon to apologise for making students feel unsafe. Beinart is unconvinced.
Culture Religion ISRAEL-PALESTINE CONFLICT HAMAS ANTI-SEMITISM JEWISH COMMUNITY OPEN DEBATE
Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Israel’s top general resigns, citing ‘terrible’ 7 October security failuresLt Gen Herzi Halevi becomes most senior Israeli figure to resign over security breakdown during 2023 Hamas attack
Read more »
October 7 attack survivor to represent Israel at EurovisionThe 24-year-old survived Hamas' massacre at the Nova music festival in 2023. Now, she's getting ready to represent Israel at one of the world's biggest song contests.
Read more »
Human rights body to consider complaint against Peter Dutton over Israel-Gaza commentaryThe Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) will consider a complaint made against Opposition Leader Peter Dutton, which accuses him of discrimination and inciting racial hatred through public statements following the Hamas terrorist attack on October 7, 2023.
Read more »
Cricket Journalist Peter Lalor Dropped by SEN Over Social Media Posts About Israel-Palestine ConflictVeteran cricket journalist Peter Lalor has been let go by SEN radio station following his social media posts about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Lalor's reposting of news stories about attacks in Gaza and the release of Palestinian prisoners sparked controversy and led to a conversation with SEN boss Craig Hutchison. Ultimately, the decision was made to part ways with Lalor due to concerns about the impact of his social media activity on the community.
Read more »
This book is so powerful, it’s hard to resist the urge to cryJewish scholar Peter Beinart imagines a world where Jews who support Israel’s bombardment of Gaza and Jews who are utterly opposed make accommodations with each other.
Read more »
A Powerful Call for Understanding in the Wake of Hamas AttacksThis news article reviews Peter Beinart's book, which explores the impact of the Hamas attacks on October 7, 2023, on the Jewish community. Beinart argues for empathy and understanding amidst the conflict, urging Jews to engage in open debate and acknowledge the suffering of Palestinians. He also condemns the use of antisemitism accusations to silence dissent.
Read more »