'Overkill': NSW Health opposed COVID testing on cruise ships

Australia News News

'Overkill': NSW Health opposed COVID testing on cruise ships
Australia Latest News,Australia Headlines
  • 📰 smh
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 56 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 26%
  • Publisher: 80%

NSW Health considered testing all cruise ship passengers for coronavirus was 'very much overkill' a month before the Ruby Princess debacle, according to emails tendered at an inquiry today | sallyrawsthorne

The Ruby Princess cruise ship, which was the source of hundreds of Australia's coronavirus cases, departs Port Kembla.On February 8, cruise ships had the world's second-largest incidence of COVID-19 infections after mainland China, the inquiry heard.

"These emails reflected that we were taking it very seriously as a major cause for concern for NSW. We were investing a lot of effort ... to best manage the risk from cruise ships. Although we understood cruise ships were always a risk of infectious disease ... the Diamond Princess experience made us all very aware of the risk," chief human biosecurity officer Dr Sean Tobin said in giving evidence on Tuesday.

In one email, Professor Ferson said it was "very much overkill" for passengers on all ships to be tested. In another, he said if a test came back negative and a passenger was subsequently diagnosed with COVID-19 “we will be asked why we missed a case and it will look worse for everyone.” Discussing the risk of an outbreak on board a cruise ship, Commissioner Bret Walker SC said while the risks are "numerically small ... in human terms [are] very important. Materialisation of the risk will include some deaths that could have been avoided."The most important news, analysis and insights delivered to your inbox at the start and end of each day. Sign up to

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

smh /  🏆 6. in AU

Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

NSW Deputy Premier 'condemns' weekend protests due to COVID-19 concerns | Sky News AustraliaNSW Deputy Premier 'condemns' weekend protests due to COVID-19 concerns | Sky News AustraliaNSW Deputy Premier John Barilaro says “everyone has a right to protest but not in this time” as the nation looks to recover from the devastating impact of the coronavirus pandemic. \n\nMass protests were held across Australia on the weekend to stand in solidarity with the United States’ Black Lives Matter movement, sparked by the death of unarmed black man George Floyd in police custody. \n\nMr Barilaro told Sky News he “condemned those marches on the weekend”. \n\n“We have just spent months and months putting lockdowns in place to protect all lives, to protect all of our communities, businesses have been hurt, the economy has been smashed – it was reckless and those protests should not have gone ahead,” he said. \n\n“I feel that we’ve had three months of messaging gone out the window. \n\n“This COVID pandemic is something that we can’t take for granted, it is something that is pausing and holding our economy to ransom – it’s a tough message but we will work with our communities that have done it right up to this point. \n\n“I’m not going to allow the protest on the weekend to determine what happens going forward, we are able to lift restrictions for the footy for instance, but that will be done under the social distancing rules.” \n\nImage: AP
Read more »

NSW records two new COVID-19 cases | Sky News AustraliaNSW records two new COVID-19 cases | Sky News AustraliaAuthorities have confirmed two new cases of the coronavirus have been confirmed in New South Wales. \n\nPremier Gladys Berejiklian said on Tuesday the state took a 'huge leap of faith' in trusting the community to adhere to distancing restrictions. \n\n'This is a partnership, business and government and community have been working together to make sure we keep NSW as COVID safe as possible,' she said. \n\n“Because we are doing well we can continue to look at the further easing of restrictions but that will be put at risk if all of us don’t keep working together to do the right thing and that is really important.' \n\nImage: AP
Read more »

NSW Police defend pepper spraying Sydney Black Lives Matter protestersNSW Police defend pepper spraying Sydney Black Lives Matter protestersNSW Police have defended using pepper spray on a group of protesters after yesterday's Black Lives Matter march in Sydney.
Read more »

NSW missing out on $8 billion a year from failure to tax land-rezoning, inquiry toldNSW missing out on $8 billion a year from failure to tax land-rezoning, inquiry toldNSW is missing out on more than $8 billion a year in revenue because of a tax system that fails to adequately capture value from land rezoning and new infrastructure, the Productivity Commission has been told | michaelkoziol
Read more »

NSW councils urge reforms to 'challenging' national environment lawsNSW councils urge reforms to 'challenging' national environment lawsCouncils in NSW have seized on a once-in-a-decade review of Australia's national environment laws to push for better recognition of local government's role in protecting biodiversity and slowing climate change.
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-04-12 08:48:41